.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

The Foxhole Philosopher

A forum for thoughtful discussion of practical issues facing the military, civil, and political world today. None of the Opinions expressed here are a reflection of United States, her Military, or any other organization other than those of the author.

Name:
Location: Iraq

4.25.2006

Hatred

There is something that I have been mulling in my mind, and this is no doubt something that will either be controversial or popular depending on who reads it. I think, that there is something different between killing someone, and killing them in wrath. Throughout the world, people die every day, and for the most part we accept it. Occasionally, people kill other people, and we sometimes accept that, depending on what the intent of the killer was. Even in the vicious times of Babylon, and Mosaic Israel there was a distinction made between murder and killing accidentally or in defense.

In war, killing necessarily comes up all the time. It is a fundamental function of a soldier that from time to time, you take a life. I think that even in that aspect, killing in wrath is bad. Of course, you kill for many reasons, to stay alive, to accomplish the mission, to save lives, and in the military we accept those. I think, however, that we also need to make the distinction that as professionals, killing out of anger is not acceptable. Not because there is a change in the death, or the outcome, but because of the negative effect that it has on us.

1 Comments:

Blogger Anne Rettenberg LCSW said...

There are actually more than two choices here. Normal killing would be killing in self-defense. Sometimes, that is what soldiers do (on behalf of their country's people) but much of the time, that is not the type of killing soldiers do. Much of the time, soldiers kill as professional murderers on behalf of an expansionist regime. This isn't killing in wrath; it is similiar to the professional hit man's hit. Actually, killing out of wrath is generally thought of as more excusable by our legal system ("mitigating circumstances"). If you're a professional soldier though, whether you're killing for defense or killing as part of the aggressive aims of an empire, obviously wrath would cloud your logic and is better avoided.

8:02 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home